11th Circut Court of Appeals Strikes Down ObamaCare's Unconstitutional Individual Mandate

by: Les Carpenter
Rational Nation USA
Birthplace of Independent Conservatism
Liberty -vs- Tyranny

Rational thought again prevails. It's now on the the High Court.

(Reuters) - The U.S. Appeals Court for the 11th Circuit, based in Atlanta, ruled 2 to 1 that Congress exceeded its authority by requiring Americans to buy coverage, but it unanimously reversed a lower court decision that threw out the entire law.

The legality of the individual mandate, a cornerstone of the healthcare law, is widely expected to be decided by the U.S. Supreme Court. Opponents have argued that without the mandate, which goes into effect in 2014, the entire law falls.

The law, adopted by Congress in 2010 after a bruising battle, is expected to be a major political issue in the 2012 elections as Obama seeks another term. All the major Republican presidential candidates have opposed it.

Skip

"This economic mandate represents a wholly novel and potentially unbounded assertion of congressional authority: the ability to compel Americans to purchase an expensive health insurance product they have elected not to buy, and to make them repurchase that insurance product every month for their entire lives," the majority said in its 207-page opinion.

Skip

"Today we have prevailed in preventing Congress from infringing on the individual liberty protected by the U.S. Constitution," Florida Attorney General Pam Bondi said.

The 11th Circuit did not agree that the entire Obama healthcare law should be tossed out. Many provisions are already being implemented, including allowing children to stay on their parents' health insurance plan until age 26 and banning lifetime coverage limits. {Full Story}

This is great news. In the battle to retain our rights to make individual choices this is certainly sweet.

If reason prevails a majority of Supreme Court Justices will find the individual mandates unconstitutional. In fact, if reason is alive and well the decision will be 9-0. Nine declaring the unconstitutionality of governmental coercion and force requiring a free individual to purchase any product against their free will.

Repeal of ObamaCare in its entirety would be the ideal.

Go here for the link to the court decision.

More excellent commentary here, here, and here.

Via: Memeorandum

Comments

  1. Gorges SmytheSat Aug 13, 10:01:00 AM EDT

    I don't put much faith in the SCOTUS to be reasonable. Look who installed some of them. Plus, you've got one turncoat.

    ReplyDelete
  2. AnonymousSat Aug 13, 11:27:00 AM EDT

    Donald in Bethel, CT says:

    I agree with Gorges.

    I am thrilled at this turn of events, but I simply cannot believe that the SCOTUS will be rational and reasonable. Remember, Sotomayor said she herself judges with emotion, not with intellect. Yikes.

    Emotional assessments and government, (to any capacity), is not a good combination. It has lead us to social engineering and socialist-leaning policies. Again, yikes.

    ReplyDelete
  3. Joe HagstromSun Aug 14, 12:04:00 AM EDT

    What the outcome of this also entails is abandoning of mandatory auto insurance laws also.

    If you want to stretch it, it means government can't mandate we pay for anything should the Supremes, five of them anyway, find this unconstitutional.

    The mandatory participation was to ensure everyone that benefits helps pay and not scam the system. It has become a bull crap political one liner about "freedom."

    It's about responsibility for one's health care costs. I figured the republicans would embrace it. But integrity and consistency are things I've learned not to expect from politicians of any ilk.

    ReplyDelete
  4. Les CarpenterSun Aug 14, 01:33:00 AM EDT

    Joe - What I am about to say is harsh. Some will find it repugnant, perhaps even lacking humanity.

    There exists no "right to health care." This is a position based on rational ethics. We may argue till death over this. But until someone can rationally, rather than emotionally, argue we have a right to healthcare, and identify where it exists in our constitution I remain unconvinced.

    Forcing a person to purchase health insurance at the point of the governmental cannon is wrong.

    Should an individual make the irrational decision to opt out, for whatever their reason, then they alone should suffer the consequences.

    The fact is ObamaCare should be scrapped in its entirety and Obama ought to call in the Swiss for some advice on their market based system with effective governmemnt oversight.

    But then again, why consider and copy something that has proven successful.

    ReplyDelete

Post a Comment

RN USA no longer accepts comments. The information presented is for reflection, contemplation, and for those seeking greater understanding and wisdom. It is for seekers and those with an open mind and heart.

Namaste


Top Posts

Gnosticism - The Gospel of Mary Magdalene - Salvation through Self-Knowledge of the Soul & Mind...

Image
  When you run after your thoughts, you are like a dog chasing a stick: every time a stick is thrown, you run after it. Instead, be like a lion who, rather than chasing after the stick, turns to face the thrower. One only throws a stick at a lion once. Milarepa “Just as it is known t hat an image of one's face is seen d epending on a mirror b ut does not really exist as a face, s o the conception of "I" exist d ependent on mind and body, b ut like the image of a face t he "I" does not at all exist as its own reality. Nagarjuna "Thanks to impermanence, everything is possible."       Nagarjuna
Read more

Our Biggest Creditor {China} Tells Us "The good old days of borrowing are over"

Image
by: Les Carpenter Rational Nation USA Birthplace o Independent Conservatism Liberty -vs- Tyranny As the chickens come home to roast... Unbelievable we have been this stupid. ( Reuters ) - Global leaders on Saturday arranged a round of emergency calls to discuss the twin debt crises in Europe and the United States that are causing turmoil in financial markets . After a week that saw $2.5 trillion wiped off global stock markets, they are under pressure to show political leadership and reassure markets that Western governments have both the will and ability to reduce their huge and growing public debt loads. French President Nicolas Sarkozy, who chairs the G7/G20 group of leading economies, conferred with Britain's Prime Minister David Cameron ahead of a call planned for this weekend by G7 finance ministers and central bankers. "They discussed the euro area and the U.S. debt downgrade. Both agreed the importance of working together, monitoring the situation closely
Read more

When and How Will it End?

Image
by: Les Carpenter Rational Nation USA Birthplace of Independent Conservatism This is America. We are an English speaking nation. We have distinct and traditional American cultural values. We have some Americans in our population who have difficulty speaking a coherent sentence. We have many who cannot construct a complete and proper sentence. Yet we find the time and the money to educate youth in Arabic and Arabic culture. Mind you this is a Federal Grant program and limited to only five select school districts. At least for now. At a cost of 1.3 millions dollars students on these select district will be required,  you heard {read} right, required as mandatory part of their curriculum to learn Arabic. This is a blatant abuse of taxpayer money, and it is indicative of the future course our nation has embarked upon under the fuzzy, misguided, and incredibly deceitful anti leadership of the current occupant of the Peoples House and Impostor in Chief. Excepts from CBSDFW on this
Read more

A Tonglen Meditation Practice for Sending and Receiving Compassion...

Image
  When you run after your thoughts, you are like a dog chasing a stick: every time a stick is thrown, you run after it. Instead, be like a lion who, rather than chasing after the stick, turns to face the thrower. One only throws a stick at a lion once. Milarepa   “Just as it is known t hat an image of one's face is seen d epending on a mirror b ut does not really exist as a face, s o the conception of "I" exist d ependent on mind and body, b ut like the image of a face t he "I" does not at all exist as its own reality."    Nagarjuna   "Thanks to impermanence, everything is possible."       Nagarjuna
Read more

It’s No Time to Be Neutral...

Image
  When you run after your thoughts, you are like a dog chasing a stick: every time a stick is thrown, you run after it. Instead, be like a lion who, rather than chasing after the stick, turns to face the thrower. One only throws a stick at a lion once. Milarepa   “Just as it is known t hat an image of one's face is seen d epending on a mirror b ut does not really exist as a face, s o the conception of "I" exist d ependent on mind and body, b ut like the image of a face t he "I" does not at all exist as its own reality."    Nagarjuna   "Thanks to impermanence, everything is possible."       Nagarjuna The time for accepting the results of an extremely troubling and possibly life changing election is here. It is also time to resist the authoritarian and fascist proclivities of DJT and the movement  he spawned. A movement built on divisiveness, xenophobia, hate, lies, and disrespect for our constitution, the rule of  law, and common decency for all s
Read more

Words For a Troubled Time...

Image
  When you run after your thoughts, you are like a dog chasing a stick: every time a stick is thrown, you run after it. Instead, be like a lion who, rather than chasing after the stick, turns to face the thrower. One only throws a stick at a lion once. Milarepa   “Just as it is known t hat an image of one's face is seen d epending on a mirror b ut does not really exist as a face, s o the conception of "I" exist d ependent on mind and body, b ut like the image of a face t he "I" does not at all exist as its own reality."    Nagarjuna   "Thanks to impermanence, everything is possible."       Nagarjuna Lion's Roar - One of the largest rituals this country engages in is casting votes, to make our marks, to say something. We may cast a vote, not only for oneself, but, for those who are ill or incarcerated, for those who are illiterate, for those who have lost interest. We do this knowing that the outcome of voting is actually something we cannot r
Read more

Taking Hold of Bodhicitta...

Image
When you run after your thoughts, you are like a dog chasing a stick: every time a stick is thrown, you run after it. Instead, be like a lion who, rather than chasing after the stick, turns to face the thrower. One only throws a stick at a lion once. Milarepa   “Just as it is known t hat an image of one's face is seen d epending on a mirror b ut does not really exist as a face, s o the conception of "I" exist d ependent on mind and body, b ut like the image of a face t he "I" does not at all exist as its own reality."    Nagarjuna   "Thanks to impermanence, everything is possible."       Nagarjuna   With joy I celebrate the virtue that relives all beings From the sorrows of the state of loss, Exalting i the happy states enjoyed By those who yet are suffering. I revel in the stores of virtue, Cause of gaining the enlightened state, And celebrate the freedom won By living from the round of pain. And in the Buddhahood of the protectors I delight And
Read more

Echo...

Image
  When you run after your thoughts, you are like a dog chasing a stick: every time a stick is thrown, you run after it. Instead, be like a lion who, rather than chasing after the stick, turns to face the thrower. One only throws a stick at a lion once. Milarepa   “Just as it is known t hat an image of one's face is seen d epending on a mirror b ut does not really exist as a face, s o the conception of "I" exist d ependent on mind and body, b ut like the image of a face t he "I" does not at all exist as its own reality."    Nagarjuna   "Thanks to impermanence, everything is possible."       Nagarjuna
Read more