Should Obama Care Be Repealed?

By: Les Carpenter III
Rational Nation USA


Just back from vacation I find myself short on time with much to do over the next three days. Posting will thusly remain light, although I will attempt to get in a post of two as time allows.

I extend a most sincere thank you to the Left Coast Rebel, The Oracular Opinion, Western Hero, and The Humble Libertarian  for plugging the hole during my brief vacation in Vermont. Thank you all so much.

As you no doubt noticed a new contributor has joined Rational Nation USA. Writing under the pen name Bastiatarian, The owner of the blog Old-Fashioned Clarity has graciously agreed to add his powerful voice for liberty and reason to the line up at. Welcome aboard and continue to "give em hell!"

And now for a brief video by The Cato Institute on ObamaCare. Or more appropriately stated on the need to repeal this monstrosity of a bill.




Now you have Cato's take on the issue. What's yours?

Comments

  1. SilverfiddleThu Jul 08, 08:01:00 PM EDT

    Oh hell ya! Repeal it. Don't fiddle around the edges, or "improve" it. Burn it down and start over! This bill did the exact opposite of what should be done. It smothers every market and price signal and offers perverse incentives that will only balloon costs.

    There ain't no free lunch!

    ReplyDelete
  2. The GriperFri Jul 09, 08:00:00 PM EDT

    Repeal it?
    one problem with that strategy is the fact that even if Congress does repeal that legislation it would require the signature of President Obama or a veto proof vote and that is unlikely.

    ReplyDelete
  3. AnonymousFri Jul 09, 09:59:00 PM EDT

    Don't just repeal it. Repeal it and enact an eternal prohibition of intervention of government in health care. (Wait, didn't we already do that with the Constitution?)

    ReplyDelete
  4. Les CarpenterSat Jul 10, 12:30:00 AM EDT

    Griper - First off let me welcome you back. It is good to hear your voice again!

    Of course we would have to hope for a veto proof vote. Perhaps after 2010?

    ReplyDelete
  5. Les CarpenterSat Jul 10, 12:32:00 AM EDT

    Bastiatarian - I do believe you have made a valid observation. Certainly from the strict constructionist view!

    ReplyDelete
  6. The GriperSat Jul 10, 04:11:00 PM EDT

    he grins, tis good to get back in the arena again, RN.

    reality would declare that there will be no veto proof Congress after the 2010 elections. the most that can be hoped for is a majority vote to repeal.

    besides that, i don't think Congress is the place for this fight. even if it was repealed that would not solve the problem as it should be solved. those who are proponents of this bill will only try again and again to get a bill like this passed until they succeed again. history shows us this with their past attempts.

    this fight belongs in the Supreme Court where bills like this can be declared unconstitutional and then require an amendment to get a bill like this passed. it is then and only then that the will of the people as well as the will of the States can be expressed, pro or con.

    ReplyDelete
  7. Les CarpenterSat Jul 10, 11:07:00 PM EDT

    Griper - Again you make valid observations.

    However, with the likely confirmation of Kagan to the Supreme court it is likely ObamaCare would stand in a SJC challenge.

    Law does not always insure the will of the people.

    America is decidedly anti ObamaCare. Yet does that really make a difference?

    ReplyDelete
  8. The GriperSun Jul 11, 12:58:00 AM EDT

    RN,
    remember, Supreme Court decisions can be overturned just as laws can be repealed in Congress.

    and remember another thing. Supreme Court decisions has been historically 5-4 decisions. it is far easier to influence the vote of a single justice than try to influence the votes of enough Congressmen in both houses to create a veto proof repeal of laws.

    ReplyDelete
  9. Les CarpenterSun Jul 11, 10:45:00 AM EDT

    Good point Griper. Perhaps you are quite right.

    Maybe with a bit of luck common sense will prevail and in either scenario ObamaCare will become history.

    ReplyDelete

Post a Comment

RN USA is a No Judgement Zone (to steal from Planet Fitness), so please, No Judgement of others. We reserve the right to delete any such comment immediately upon detection.

All views are welcome. As long as the comment is on topic and respectful of others.


Top Posts

The "Scandal" That Won't Go Away...

by: Les Carpenter Rational Nation USA Lib erty -vs- Tyr anny CBS - Obama administration officials who were in key positions on Sept. 11, 2012, acknowledge that a range of mistakes were made the night of the attacks on the U.S. missions in Benghazi, and in messaging to Congress and the public in the aftermath. The officials spoke to CBS News in a series of interviews and communications under the condition of anonymity so that they could be more frank in their assessments. They do not all agree on the list of mistakes and it's important to note that they universally claim that any errors or missteps did not cost lives and reflect "incompetence rather than malice or cover up." Nonetheless, in the eight months since the attacks, this is the most sweeping and detailed discussion by key players of what might have been done differently. "We're portrayed by Republicans as either being lying or idiots," said one Obama administration official who was part
Read more

Our Biggest Creditor {China} Tells Us "The good old days of borrowing are over"

Image
by: Les Carpenter Rational Nation USA Birthplace o Independent Conservatism Liberty -vs- Tyranny As the chickens come home to roast... Unbelievable we have been this stupid. ( Reuters ) - Global leaders on Saturday arranged a round of emergency calls to discuss the twin debt crises in Europe and the United States that are causing turmoil in financial markets . After a week that saw $2.5 trillion wiped off global stock markets, they are under pressure to show political leadership and reassure markets that Western governments have both the will and ability to reduce their huge and growing public debt loads. French President Nicolas Sarkozy, who chairs the G7/G20 group of leading economies, conferred with Britain's Prime Minister David Cameron ahead of a call planned for this weekend by G7 finance ministers and central bankers. "They discussed the euro area and the U.S. debt downgrade. Both agreed the importance of working together, monitoring the situation closely
Read more

Looking To 2016...

by: Les Carpenter Rational Nation U S A Purveyor of Truth Following last nights rather mundane and short on specifics SOTU by President Obama I started thinking about the future and if there is anyone in the current ranks of the GOP or the Libertarian Party who could possibly be elected to the presidency in 2016. Frankly given the crop of malcontents and loonies(Christie doesn't fall into that group but he has shot himself in the big toe) that seem to be getting attention in the GOP it appears unlikely. Tonight while browsing the net the following article popped up and given the headline was along my line of thinking last it was a must read. Got me thinking again and if the GOP can find the intelligence to act along the lines of thought presented in the article there may just be a real race in 2016 rather than a shoo in for the democrats. NationalJournal - For a party that's accustomed to nominating the next-in-line presidential candidate, 2016 promises to be a very un
Read more

The Ignorance and Arrogance of Obama...

Image
by: Les Carpenter Rational Nation USA Liberty -vs- Tyranny In my opinion the President, in his attack on the United States Supreme court belies both his basic ignorance of our republic as well as his arrogance. His last uttering in and of itself is enough to deny the man, and I use the term loosely in this case, another term as President. Forgive me my rational liberal friends but his recent statement is more telling of his statist leanings than anything he has heretofore said. With this last he has proven beyond any doubt he is indeed clueless. The Washington Post - There was something rather unsettling in President Obama’s preemptive strike on the Supreme Court at Monday’s news conference. “I’d just remind conservative commentators that for years what we’ve heard is the biggest problem on the bench is judicial activism or a lack of judicial restraint — that an unelected group of people would somehow overturn a duly constituted and passed law,” Obama said. “Well, here’s a
Read more

Spoken Like a True Dyed In the Blue Statist...

Image
by: Les Carpenter Rational Nation U S A Purveyor of Truth Ever hear of or read Mother Jones ? Well I just did, and as near as I can figure she must be Woodrow Wilson's or Franklin Delano Roosevelt's Mother. I say this because she sure as hell is pro statist and pumped up for growing the government bureaucracy. The article is short so it is being reproduced here in full. This site appreciates Mother Jones candor in expressing the statist credo and the desire on the part of the left for an ever larger and more intrusive presence in our daily affairs and lives. January's job numbers were fairly dismal, but the bad cheer wasn't equally spread. Private sector employment, as usual, increased—by 142,000 jobs last month. At the same time, public sector employment declined. Government employment at all levels was down 29,000 in January. Aside from the brief census blip in early 2010, this has been the usual state of affairs for the past four years, ever since the rece
Read more

The ObamaCare Divide Creating Two America's...

Image
by: Les Carpenter Rational Nation USA Purveyor of Truth Red and blue state map, based on returns in last four presidential elections. (Wikimedia Commons/ Angr) This site is not a supporter of the mechanisms of ObamaCare and questions whether it in fact will ultimately make health care either more accessible r affordable. Except for those receiving a subsidy or are getting it free. All that aside I do agree with following Moyers & Company article stating that ObamaCare is widening the gap between red America and blue America. Something needed to be done with our health care and insurance system. Most agree that the pre ObamaCare system needed some work. Unfortunately reason failed American politics and what we have achieved is an ever more polorized country with no end to the polarization. Perhaps it is time to officially form a Blue United States of America and a Red United States of America. Because in reality we are moving ever closer to the breaking point. Th
Read more

Race Baiting at the Highest Level of the Federal Government...?

by: Les Carpenter Rational Nation USA Lib e rty -vs- Tyr a nny I listened to the full Presidential news conference this afternoon. Obama said some things that made sense. Then he made the following remarks that IMNHO told the nation in full agenda with respect to said issue. Having a in depth discussion of race relations might very well be appropriate and a general discussion is something that MOST American's would welcome. Using the Zimmerman verdict ks simply the WRONG event at possibly the right time. However, don't expect the President, the Department of Justice, or the liberal media or ultra liberal populace to understand what this means. If I can find a video of the full and complete news conference it will be posted later. Via: Memeorandum     Update : via You Tube.    Your views and thoughts are most welcome. Left and or Right leaning...
Read more

More Thoughts On Reasonable Firearm Control...

Image
by: Les Carprnter Rational Nation USA Liberty -vs- Tyranny In the wake of the Sandy Hook tragedy in which 20 innocent children lost their live to a sick and mentally unstable individual the subject of gun control has remained center stage. This is understandable, and as it should be. The pursuit of finding improved methods to better identify unstable individuals and thereby keep firearms out of the hands of such individuals is a worthy pursuit. As we consider how to deal with increasing societal violence we must find a happy medium that will both improve public safety and preserve our second amendment rights. It can be done, if both sides of the gun control debate will start listening to each other rather talking A T each other. We have heard from the NRA's Wayne LaPierre, who has offered essentially the same solution as the organization did in 2007. Put armed police guards in every school in America. Not anything most suburban and rural Mom's and Dad's will b
Read more